Casper animal advocates attempt to reduce cat and dog euthanasia

2013-03-26T06:00:00Z Casper animal advocates attempt to reduce cat and dog euthanasiaBy KELLY BYER Star-Tribune staff writer Casper Star-Tribune Online

Twenty-seven dogs and seven cats were euthanized in 2012 because the Casper city shelter ran out of space. Another 253 cats were killed because they were feral and less likely to be adopted.

Animal care and service workers want those numbers at zero. They are working to make it happen, but it all begins with a comprehensive spay and neuter program.

“Our overpopulation problem in Casper is insane,” said Lindsey Tempest, founder of Tempest Critter Rescue.

She coordinates low-cost clinics in Casper to treat the problem, but she said a few visits a year are hardly enough. The Jackson-based Spay/Neuter Wyoming Program serves people who earn less than $30,000 per year, and the mobile Spay Doc clinic out of Colorado is open to anyone.

Both fill fast. Spay/Neuter Wyoming founder Heather Carlton said that in February, 80 people had already registered for the next Casper clinic in May. She usually takes 160 animals per visit.

Tempest has stopped advertising because of the overwhelming response. In February, she posted a notice on Facebook and had the Spay Doc clinic filled in 48 hours. The resulting wait list amounted to about 40 people.

“I could probably book them every day for a month and would still have a wait list,” she said.

Cost of critter care

The low-cost clinics offer spays or neuters for $15 to $60 depending on animal type and size.

By comparison, a spay or neuter at a private animal hospital can cost anywhere from $59 to $300. Most operations average between $100 and $200, according to local vet rates.

Shye Virgilio, who helps raise funds for area rescue groups, said the low-cost clinics provide a much-needed service because the animals may not see a vet otherwise.

“I think that’s probably going to be what saves Casper from becoming all cats and dogs,” she said. “Because it’s outrageous, the prices to get your animal spayed and neutered.”

Richard Schwahn, a doctor at Altitude Veterinary Hospital, said procedures at his clinic average about $300 and include physical exams, medications and anesthesia. Prices differ by clinic, as do services.

Schwahn said he urges people to consider animal health care costs before buying or adopting a pet.

“I know we like to have responsible pet owners, but sometimes people can’t afford it,” he said.

For those who need assistance, Schwann said he recommends the Central Wyoming Spay/Neuter Foundation. The nonprofit generally provides $50 to $80 vouchers to anyone who qualifies as low- to moderate-income.

Mobile clinic and rescue workers reported a less-than-ideal relationship with local veterinarians, but Schwahn said his center regularly helps other animal service groups such as Paws2Help and can’t assist clinics.

“We’re just busy enough the way we are,” he said. “We’re not able to help.”

Schwann admitted the low-cost clinics could be considered competition.

Kate Gies, with the Spay Doc mobile clinic, and Tempest said their goal is not to take business but treat animals, many advanced in age, whose owners can’t afford a private animal hospital.

“It’s just not happening,” Gies said. “So we try to fill that need.”

Fixing problems

Aside from adding to the population and overcrowding shelters, letting unaltered animals abound spreads disease and increases the risk of reproductive cancers.

Animal-to-animal reproductive diseases and rabies could potentially spread from unvaccinated feral animals to domestic pets. Animals in heat also tend to wander, mark their territory and exhibit destructive behavior more often than spayed or neutered animals.

For those reasons, Gies said fixed animals are less likely to be abandoned.

“They’re much better pets,” she said. “They’re much less likely to end up in the shelter.”

Feral animals can be an annoyance to the neighborhoods they frequent, as well. In Casper, Tempest said she targets areas northeast of the city where she knows overpopulation is at its worst, and Schwahn said he sees cats living under trailers and inside barns.

“When it comes to the pet population situation, we just know that there’s pockets of cats out there,” Schwahn said. “Feral cats.”

Animals that end up at a shelter stand a better chance if they are domesticated and spayed/neutered, two things feral felines are not. Justine Tuma, a kennel technician at Metro, said wild cats are often put down because they are not adoptable.

“They’re usually high rate of euthanasia compared to dogs,” she said.

Metro killed more than 200 feral cats last year. It’s one solution to the problem, but animal advocates are convinced a less objectionable option exists.

“Those cats end up euthanized in huge numbers because they’re feral when it could all just be prevented,” Gies said.

Attacking the source

In an effort to prevent the unnecessary deaths of unwanted animals, rescue groups and clinic staff members are fighting to contain the existing population and prevent further growth.

The low-cost clinics have immense support from local rescues in Casper, but there’s room to grow when it comes to local practices. Carlton said veterinarians help out in Rock Springs, Star Valley, Jackson, Riverton and Lander. One Casper vet, who Carlton didn’t want to name because of the potential backlash, does assist with extra clinic clients. In Gillette, Green River and Lyman, animal shelters create a list for the clinic and suggest the services to pet owners who need it.

“In my mind, that’s ideal because the shelters know who has money and who doesn’t have the money,” Carlton said. “They know the people who keep bringing in puppies every year, kittens every year because they’re not spaying their animals.”

It costs her about $5,000 for each clinic. In the future, she hopes to put the money into vouchers instead of a physical surgery center. With funding from the city of Rock Springs, she is testing that format.

“If this works, it’s a whole lot easier for me to send the town money to match them, motivate them to do a voucher program, than it is to haul equipment around,” she said.

The Central Wyoming Spay/Neuter Foundation currently provides vouchers to low-income individuals, and applications are available at Metro. Interim Director Scott Schell said the shelter does not spay or neuter animals before they are adopted but requires the procedure. The shelter checks with the family and their veterinarian after about 30 days to confirm the surgery was performed.

Schell said it would be easier to spay and neuter animals before releasing them, but it might affect current adoption prices.

“Right now, it’s not in our budget,” he said.

To deal with the population of feral animals already prowling the city, Spay Doc is seeking funding for a Trap/Neuter/Release (TNR) program. A PetSmart grant made TNR possible in Douglas, and Gies said she would like to start the program in Casper.

By trapping wild cats, fixing and releasing them, it controls the population. Tempest said she’s already used live traps on a few occasions for the same purpose. Cats are territorial and will keep other strays from moving in.

“You have your community cat,” she said. “It’s going to keep your mouse problem down. They’re not going to be reproducing, and then you’re not going to have unaltered ones moving in.”

Slow results

In the fall of 2009, Carlton’s clinic began visiting Casper. She tracks kill-shelter rates across the state and said that since then, the city shelter has decreased its euthanasia rate by about 45 percent.

Carlton said the clinics also benefit local shelters by saving them money and the emotional distress of euthanizing otherwise healthy animals.

“I’m hoping that we can make a difference,” she said. “And we can stop using euthanasia as a form of animal control.”

Although euthanasia statistics for years prior to 2012 were unavailable, Schell agreed that there has been a general decrease in the practice at Metro.

“With the help that we get from the rescue groups, it’s not a massive euthanasia like it used to be when I first started years ago,” he said.

Schell has spent 14 years at the shelter and said in recent years, animals might be euthanized a few times per month during the busy season of spring and summer when Metro runs out of room.

Even that could be avoided.

Gies said she’s witnessed similar cities such as Chadron, Neb., fix the pet population in less than five years with comprehensive spay and neuter efforts. The result is fewer animals in shelters and fewer killed for lack of space.

“Casper could be a no-kill community,” she said.

“We definitely could,” Tempest agreed.

Reach city reporter Kelly Byer at 307-266-0639 or Follow her on Twitter @KellyByer.

Copyright 2015 Casper Star-Tribune Online. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(9) Comments

  1. Spay Doc
    Report Abuse
    Spay Doc - March 28, 2013 11:59 am
    This is about people sharing their time and talents to reduce the suffering of animals caused by overpopulation. The numbers quoted by Dr. Carlton are why we all do what we do. Our sincere gratitude to all who give so much to help those who have no voice.
  2. Rosie79
    Report Abuse
    Rosie79 - March 27, 2013 11:36 am
    Once again, you get what you pay for. I'm glad EastSide has struck your cheap animal care fancy, there should be a place for everyone. And I think it' s smart to gauge the level of care by how little someone charges. You think the same way with your own health care?
  3. nls
    Report Abuse
    nls - March 27, 2013 10:56 am
    Well I go to east side Marie and she does not charge outrageous prices she loves animals.. And there are not that many in town believe me I have had a ton of animals over the years and tried almost every place in town, There are certain ones in this town that are there for the money I don't give a crap what you say its all about money for certain places and there is more than one I am talking about.
  4. Rosie79
    Report Abuse
    Rosie79 - March 27, 2013 10:38 am
    I keep seeing the same Vet being used to make a point about all Vets. Flashback, I said a majority...not all. And you can believe all you want, sure doesn't make it true. You think for one second the traveling fix a cat bus is not in it, just a smidgen, for the money? Do the math friend, let's say they do 50 spay and neutered at an average of $50. That's $2500 for one day of work. And it would be pretty silly to think they only work in Casper for the one to two day a year extravaganza. They could hit 5 different towns in a week and make over $12,0000. When was the last time you made that kind of money? And it's so strange to me that you think the less you have to spend...the more they care. Did you ever think that maybe they can charge less because they do a minimal service. None of those animals get sent home with pain medications, nor do they have a phone number or Mobil office to return to next day when little Max is vomiting or Angel's incision has popped open. Another get what you pay for.
  5. nls
    Report Abuse
    nls - March 27, 2013 7:01 am
    Some of them don't need to charge double what other vets are charging.. Like Altitude.. So give me a break. Sure there are people who should never own a pet.. But when some wants a pet and adopts and has never had a pet.. and goes to get the dog fixed and its 300 dollars. that does not sound outrageous to you.. Whatever.. And I believe these traveling clinics offer just as good as care as any vet in this town.. I have a story for you we had two horses asked the Vet on outer drive the new one. to come out and look at them cause there is not many vets for horses that will come to your house. 3 dr. came out which was weird they where there for 1 hour. LOOKED at them said they were old told us to give them a supplement from them. Charged us 600 dolllars. For NOTHING. and there supplement was 200 which we did not buy... Now you tell me. was this caused they cared NOT that was all about the money.
  6. Rosie79
    Report Abuse
    Rosie79 - March 26, 2013 7:09 pm
    What's OUTRAGEOUS is that people are adopting or purchasing these animals and can't afford their basic needs. Veterinarians go to school for a very long time, they have a staff to pay for, equipment to pay for, medications to pay for. This all adds up. If you want your animal fixed for cheap...well you get what you pay for. Yes, these clinics are beneficial in their own regard, but to call local vets greedy, or claim that they are " financial rapist" is ridiculous. A majority of your local vets DO care about that oath they took, and that is why they give the animals pain medications, they keep the animals for observation, and they are there the next day or next week or WHENEVER you need them in the case something goes wrong. Are the prices higher than that of the clinic? Well yes they are but so is the level of care your animal will receive.
  7. bossmare
    Report Abuse
    bossmare - March 26, 2013 6:19 pm
    Casper's vets have always been high. I got a routine rabies shot for a cat I found and it was $50 dollars. The shot costs about two dollars on line but you can't give those yourself. It's just crazy what they charge for neutering a cat or dog! Casper has a real need for these clinics and its a good thing that Tempest Critter Rescue brings in SpayDoc, he did my kitten and did an excellent job. $59 dollars to separate a tom cat from his knackers is crazy, 300 is crazier still!
  8. nls
    Report Abuse
    nls - March 26, 2013 10:45 am
    I agree But the traveling one is good though.. The altitude I can't believe it People are stupid if they take there pets to that place( previous Popish) they have always been high And really not they great of service.. Really sad . But I think the traveling one from colorado is just great, That's a vet who is doing it for the love of the animals. Good for you.
  9. JOLENE82601
    Report Abuse
    JOLENE82601 - March 26, 2013 9:58 am
    Those prices for spay/neuter in Casper are OUTRAGEOUS. Really??? I have owned pets all my 46 years and have NEVER heard of such high fees. Nothing like financial rape by greedy people. Remember vets--you took an oath the same as a "regular" doc. Shouldn't be about all the $$$$$$$$ (money),but LOVE OF ANIMALS.
Untitled Document

Civil Dialogue

We provide this community forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on the news of the day. Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude language and personal abuse are not welcome. Moderators will monitor comments with an eye toward maintaining a high level of civility in this forum. Our comment policy explains the rules of the road for registered commenters.

If your comment was not approved, perhaps...

  1. You called someone an idiot, a racist, a dope, a moron, etc. Please, no name-calling or profanity (or veiled profanity -- #$%^&*).

  2. You rambled, failed to stay on topic or exhibited troll-like behavior intended to hijack the discussion at hand.

  3. YOU SHOUTED YOUR COMMENT IN ALL CAPS. This is hard to read and annoys readers.

  4. You have issues with a business. Have a bad meal? Feel you were overcharged at the store? New car is a lemon? Contact the business directly with your customer service concerns.

  5. You believe the newspaper's coverage is unfair. It would be better to write the editor at, or call Editor Jason Adrians at 266-0545 or Content Director David Mayberry at 266-0633. This is a forum for community discussion, not for media criticism. We'd rather address your concerns directly.

  6. You included an e-mail address or phone number, pretended to be someone you aren't or offered a comment that makes no sense.

  7. You accused someone of a crime or assigned guilt or punishment to someone suspected of a crime.

  8. Your comment is in really poor taste.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Featured Businesses

Latest Offers