John Guy Carlton brought a loaded pistol when he went to confront the man he suspected was supplying his girlfriend’s son with methamphetamine. A struggle ensued and the weapon fired, wounding the alleged dealer.

All three men will wake this morning behind bars.

A judge Tuesday sentenced Carlton to six months in the Natrona County Detention Center for the shooting and for marijuana found at his Mills home. The man he injured, Jason Michael Johnson, is incarcerated in the same jail while awaiting trial on unrelated weapons possession charges.

And the teenager that Carlton said he was trying to protect? Carver Fischer is serving three to five years for meth possession.

At his sentencing hearing in Natrona County District Court, Carlton said he was simply trying to keep his girlfriend safe while scaring Johnson. He initially told detectives the gun fired when he pistol-whipped the victim, but now claims it went off when Johnson went for the weapon.

“I’m very sorry for what I did and I never meant for anybody to get hurt,” Carlton told the court.

Judge Thomas Sullins was unmoved. He declined to sentence Carlton to probation, reasoning the defendant’s violent act and lengthy criminal history warranted jail time.

The shooting occurred during an April 4 altercation at Highland Cemetery. Earlier that day, Carlton and his girlfriend tried to convince Johnson to stop selling to Fischer, the defendant told police.

Johnson eventually left, but met with them again that evening at Highland Cemetery. Carlton’s girlfriend spoke first. As she walked back to her car, Carlton approached Johnson. When he felt his message wasn’t sinking in, Carlton pulled a pistol from his pants and pointed it at Johnson’s head.

“You think she is crazy?” he said, according to his statement to police. “You haven’t met me.”

Johnson was shot moments later. He tried to walk to a nearby hospital, but nearly passed out. Paramedics ultimately had to assist him.

Defense attorney Vaughn Neubauer portrayed his client as a man in an impossible situation. Carlton sought help several times from police and probation officers in the two weeks leading up to the shooting, without success.

“Someone he loved was spiraling out of control and he can’t get help from authorities,” Neubauer said.

Carlton did not contact police on the day of the confrontation. Nor was he initially involved in the confrontation at the cemetery. He remained at his car, and only approached once his girlfriend was finished, noted Assistant District Attorney Dan Itzen.

“The basic premise of our law is you do not take it into your own hands,” he said. “You simply don’t go out and settle a score.”

And while it might appear courageous for Carlton to confront a drug dealer, the defendant was “hip deep” in drugs himself, Itzen said. After the shooting, police found drugs and drug paraphernalia at Carlton’s home and in shed outside.

Johnson was not charged in connection to the incident. However, he does have a past aggravated assault conviction.

Contact Joshua Wolfson at 307-266-0582 or at Visit to read his blog. Follow him on Twitter @joshwolfson.

(2) comments


sounds like he tried to get help for the kid for two weeks before this happened? judge says that he was hip deep in drugs because he had some marijuana? same courthouse a judge was going to rec probation for another guy who put a pistol to a ladies head with kids in the backseat so they wouldnt see him kill her-i cant figure the judges in this town out at all, what this guy did isnt right but he should have got probation.


Sorry but that deserves jail. You point or shoot a gun at someone you need to go to jail. Maybe you'd feel different if you ever experienced such a thing.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.