Commentary: Deporting worker makes America less safe
AP

Commentary: Deporting worker makes America less safe

{{featured_button_text}}

On Oct. 12, construction worker Delmer Joel Ramirez Palma was working on the Hard Rock Hotel in New Orleans when the structure collapsed, killing three workers and injuring dozens more. He survived a fall of three flights by swinging on a rope, although he sustained serious injuries.

Ramirez, who has done construction work in the New Orleans area for 18 years, had on multiple occasions before the collapse raised safety concerns with his supervisor, including measurements showing that the building was not level. Immediately following the collapse, he was interviewed by the Spanish-language media outlet Jambalaya News.

Two days later, Ramirez's world came crashing down again. While on a recuperative fishing trip in Louisiana's Bayou Sauvage National Wildlife Refuge, he was approached by U.S. Fish and Wildlife officers and asked to produce a fishing license, which he did.

Ramirez was then asked for a driver's license, which he didn't have. The officers summoned Border Patrol agents, who placed him under arrest. Like many undocumented workers, Ramirez had an outstanding deportation order. He had been challenging that order, and he had been regularly reporting to ICE. But now, suddenly, he was in detention.

While in ICE custody, Ramirez - an important witness to this tragic event - was interviewed three times by the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). That agency is investigating the collapse, to determine whether safety violations occurred and, if so, which parties should be held accountable. It is also looking into whether Ramirez's arrest and detention relate to his complaints about the building's condition or his comments to the press. Retaliation, if it was involved, is illegal.

Ramirez, who is married with three children, spent Thanksgiving in ICE custody. The following day he was deported to his native Honduras.

There's something seriously wrong here.

The secretary of the Louisiana Workforce Commission calls Ramirez a "crucial witness" in the ongoing investigation. His advocates and several public officials argue that whisking him away undeniably chills other workers at the Hard Rock Hotel work site. Those workers are painfully aware that Ramirez spoke out and was deported - a fate they understandably fear could be theirs if they similarly come forward with information.

There are an estimated 8 million immigrant workers in the United States without proper work authorization. They routinely suffer employers' threats to "call ICE" if they raise safety concerns or assert their right to overtime pay. Consequently, violations of their rights under federal worker protection laws - which don't condition protection on documented status - remain hidden. That allows exploitation of these workers to continue and unsafe conditions to go unreported.

This can also affect workers without immigration concerns. When they see their co-workers deported or threatened into silence, the broader message of intimidation isn't hard to detect.

Aggressive enforcement of our immigration laws obstructs the protection of all workers. That's why, on Nov. 21, Democratic lawmakers reintroduced the POWER (Protect Our Workers from Exploitation and Retaliation) Act. It provides new protections for undocumented workers, and thus helps ensure that enforcement of federal immigration policy doesn't undermine all workers' basic job-related rights. It deserves bipartisan support.

In the meantime, we need workers to speak out about potentially unsafe and unlawful conditions at work, without fear of deportation. And we need the government to recognize how important that is, for the benefit of all workers, regardless of their immigration status.

Delmer Ramirez-Palma's deportation doesn't make America great. It makes us all less safe, less able to prevent the next Hard Rock-like tragedy. He deserves to be returned to this country, for the public good.

___

ABOUT THE WRITER

Michael Felsen of Jamaica Plain, Mass., retired in 2018 after a 39-year career as an attorney with the Department of Labor, serving from 2010-2018 as its New England Regional Solicitor. This column was produced for the Progressive Media Project, which is run by The Progressive magazine, and distributed by Tribune News Service.

0
0
0
0
0

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

If a policymaker proposed banning cars and trucks or reducing the speed limit to 5 mph to reduce traffic fatalities, he or she would be laughed off the stage. Such a policy ignores the benefits of driving and disregards how people accept risk and tradeoffs in their lives. So why should we treat efforts to ban fracking any different? Hydraulic fracturing, better known as fracking, is safe. ...

Do you think it is permissible to yell "fire" in a crowded movie theater in order to create a panic? How about whether it is legal to speak to a crowd and tell them to go out and shoot the first police officer they see, or homeless person or teacher? If you responded no to those questions, does that make you an opponent of the First Amendment and its ban on laws that abridge the freedom of ...

  • Updated

We have stepped through the looking glass, or entered George Orwell's dystopia. Criminals are victims. Public servants are criminals. Truth is a lie, and lies told loudly and persistently carry the day. We are at a tipping point where the bedrocks of our society are under attack. President Donald Trump commuted Rod Blagojevich's sentence Tuesday. Blagojevich will loudly proclaim his innocence, ...

Four principled prosecutors resigned from the Roger Stone case on Feb. 11. They did so rather than be complicit in Donald Trump's attempt to soften the sentence for Stone, his underling who was convicted of crimes in a case arising from the Mueller investigation into Russia's 2016 election interference. Even more than the past resignations on principle by others serving in the Trump ...

  • Updated

Welcome to the 21st century nuclear arms race. Once again, we're teetering on the brink of nuclear conflict instead of taking critical steps toward de-escalation and disarmament. If it feels like we're in the middle of a wacky James Bond movie plot, that's not far off. Any progress we were making toward nuclear safety is being rapidly, systematically and recklessly dismantled by the Trump ...

All of the Democratic candidates for president are well qualified, and all of them could potentially defeat President Donald Trump, but not one of them has made a genuine effort to unite some core ideas of moderates and conservatives with progressive ideas. For all of the talk about the centrists vs. the progressives - Joe Biden, Amy Klobuchar, Pete Buttigieg and Michael Bloomberg vs. Bernie ...

  • Updated

It's rarely a good thing when a journalist becomes a central part of a sensitive and controversial story she's trying to tell. Gayle King, "CBS This Morning" co-host, has been in the middle of firestorm over the questions she asked former WNBA star Lisa Leslie about the effect of Kobe Bryant's 2003 sexual assault allegation on his legacy. I've been introspective and conflicted about this ...

  • Updated

Conservative Catholics, including some critics of Pope Francis, are doing a victory lap because the pope has not, as expected, endorsed the ordination of married men as priests in the Amazon region of South America. At a Vatican synod it in October, two-thirds of bishops from that area had supported an exception to Western Catholicism's celibacy requirement to deal with a severe shortage of ...

The COVID-19 virus is a human tragedy for many who have been affected by it and it's having a profound impact on the lives of a large part of the Chinese population. The impact on the rest of the world of the disease's dislocation of the Chinese economy is yet to be fully felt. Forecasts of only a modest impact on oil demand worldwide are far too optimistic. A comparison of the latest ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News