Commentary: Did Pope Francis acquiesce to conservatives on married priests? Sure looks like it
AP

Commentary: Did Pope Francis acquiesce to conservatives on married priests? Sure looks like it

{{featured_button_text}}
Pope Francis meets the Crown Prince of Bahrain Salman bin Hamad bin Isa Al-Khalifa during an audience at the Apostolic Palace at the Vatican on Feb. 3, 2020. Pope Francis did not support a proposal to let married men serve as priests in the Amazon region.

Pope Francis meets the Crown Prince of Bahrain Salman bin Hamad bin Isa Al-Khalifa during an audience at the Apostolic Palace at the Vatican on Feb. 3, 2020. Pope Francis did not support a proposal to let married men serve as priests in the Amazon region. (Abaca Press/TNS)

Conservative Catholics, including some critics of Pope Francis, are doing a victory lap because the pope has not, as expected, endorsed the ordination of married men as priests in the Amazon region of South America. At a Vatican synod it in October, two-thirds of bishops from that area had supported an exception to Western Catholicism's celibacy requirement to deal with a severe shortage of priests.

The pope had been expected to endorse that idea. But he declined to do so after a firestorm that included the publication of a pro-celibacy book, "From the Depths of our Hearts," that originally listed Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI as a co-author. (The principal author of the book is Cardinal Robert Sarah, a prominent church conservative, but Benedict did contribute some reflections.)

In an "apostolic exhortation" about the Amazon made public Wednesday, Francis didn't announce a change in the celibacy rule for that region. Instead he suggested other ways to deal with the priest shortage such as encouraging bishops in other countries to encourage missionaries to "opt for the Amazon region."

The pope's decision is rightly being described as a victory for conservatives who cherish the celibacy rule. But it may have broader and more ominous implications, not just for Catholics of the so-called Eastern-rite churches, in which married men may be ordained priests, but for the prospects of reunion between Rome and Eastern Orthodox churches.

As I explained here, there are already married Catholic priests. Most minister in the Eastern rites, which share traditions, liturgy and theology with ancient churches such as the Eastern Orthodox that don't recognize the pope. But there are also Catholic priests who were previously Anglican, Episcopal or Lutheran clergy who were allowed to be ordained Catholic priests even though they were married. (Ironically, it was Benedict XVI who in a 2009 decree paved the way for large-scale ordination of married former Anglican clergymen.)

The Vatican's acceptance of married priests in Eastern-rite churches has been grudging at times. In the early 20th century, it prohibited those churches from ordaining married men in North America, South America and Australia, a concession to Roman Catholic bishops in those places who were worried that their faithful would be scandalized by the presence of married Catholic priests in their midst. That prohibition was lifted only in 2014.

Granted, Francis' decision not to create a new exception to the celibacy rule preserves the status quo. But coming after the controversy over the retired Pope Benedict's contribution to "From the Depths of our Hearts," it might be seen as a retreat from the Roman Catholic Church's position that its celibacy requirement is a matter of discipline, not doctrine.

That's because excerpts from Benedict's contribution to the book suggest that the retired pope sees an absolute incompatibility between priesthood and the married life. Benedict wrote: "From the daily celebration of the Eucharist, which implies a permanent state of service to God, was born spontaneously the impossibility of a marital bond."

To say that it's impossible for priests to be married seems to elevate the ban on celibacy to the status of doctrine, calling into question the legitimacy of the vocations of married clergy who already minister in the Catholic Church. On Thursday the Washington Post charmingly profiled one such priest, a cleric in the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. "Married priests are not above the folks," the Rev. Oleh Kindiy told the Post. "My wife is friends with the parishioners. My kids are growing up with parishioners' kids."

Especially in light of Benedict's intervention, Francis' refusal to relax the celibacy rule for the Amazon also sends a discouraging signal to the Eastern churches not in communion with the pope - that reunion with Rome could render their married priests second-class clergy.

I'm sure the pope didn't intend to demean the ministry of married priests - Catholic and non-Catholic - with this decision. But it could have that effect.

___

ABOUT THE WRITER

Michael McGough is the Los Angeles Times' senior editorial writer, based in Washington, D.C.

Visit the Los Angeles Times at www.latimes.com

0
0
0
0
0

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

If a policymaker proposed banning cars and trucks or reducing the speed limit to 5 mph to reduce traffic fatalities, he or she would be laughed off the stage. Such a policy ignores the benefits of driving and disregards how people accept risk and tradeoffs in their lives. So why should we treat efforts to ban fracking any different? Hydraulic fracturing, better known as fracking, is safe. ...

Some Democrats complain about billionaire former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg trying to buy the election, but at least he's doing it with his own money. President Trump is using yours. Let's break down that Friday morning tweet. Farmers are being "formally targeted" by foreign countries because Trump picked a trade war with the entire globe, first with tariffs on solar panels, then ...

"The most beautiful scene in all the blue Pacific today is an American Flag whipping the breeze on the top of the Suribachi volcano." - From the Feb. 24, 1945, Evening Sun Seventy-five years ago this month, the United States military forces were fighting the bloodiest battle in their history. And a Baltimore Sun foreign correspondent was there to catch the scoop of a lifetime. Iwo Jima, an ...

New reporting about last spring's devastating fire at Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris - and, specifically, how the world-renowned structure is still at risk of collapse - offers yet another reminder of the fragility of humankind's greatest creations and the stark reality that centuries of culture and history can be wiped out in minutes. Several years ago, in spring 2016, I was at the Uffizi ...

The word "tribalism" has become shorthand for everything toxic and ugly about politics in the Trump era. It's meant to convey not just brute partisanship, but also how uncivilized and unthinking this divisiveness has made us. There is good reason, though, to drop the metaphor. "Tribes" were rarely this polarized. What's more, an understanding of actual social life among indigenous groups may ...

Bernie Sanders, the front-runner for the Democratic presidential nomination, is a Jewish socialist. One of his major challengers, Michael Bloomberg, is a Jewish billionaire who made his fortune on Wall Street. What's wrong with this picture? You don't have to be a Jew or a historian - and I'm both - to know the answer. Across the past century, anti-Semites have reviled Jews as both rapacious ...

On Feb. 8, the night before I went to a vigil for Dr. Li Wenliang in New York's Central Park, one of my friends warned me: "Wear a mask and sunglasses. Don't show your face. Protect yourself." I thanked her for her kindness but decided not to wear any "protection." What danger would I face if I'm just mourning a doctor who had saved countless lives by being a "whistleblower" about the rapidly ...

  • Updated

Jeff Bezos dropped $165 million two weeks ago for the most expensive residential property in the history of Los Angeles. That's about an eighth of 1% of his $131.9-billion net worth. Bezos' purchase is like a regular person forking over just $121 for a house, given that the Federal Reserve says the median net worth of an American is $97,300. Bezos' home, nestled on nine acres in Beverly Hills, ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News