Commentary: Trump seems to think money is free right now. It isn't

Commentary: Trump seems to think money is free right now. It isn't

U.S. President Donald Trump takes questions from reporters in the Rose Garden for the daily coronavirus briefing at the White House on March 29, 2020 in Washington, DC.

U.S. President Donald Trump takes questions from reporters in the Rose Garden for the daily coronavirus briefing at the White House on March 29, 2020 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images/TNS)

President Donald Trump proclaimed himself the "king of debt" during the 2016 campaign, and he does have a long history of borrowing huge amounts that he often repays. So it was curious to see a tweet from him on Tuesday that grossly misstated the cost of federal borrowing.

In the tweet, Trump reaffirmed his on-again, off-again support for a giant federal effort to improve roads, bridges and other infrastructure in this country. He famously reached a deal with top congressional Democrats in April 2019 to support a $2-trillion program of upgrades, only to lose interest in the idea. But Democrats have never given up on the idea of a huge, debt-financed effort to rebuild and improve U.S. infrastructure, and the idea has taken on new urgency in recent weeks as a way to help stimulate the plunging economy.

More on the wisdom of that in a bit. But first, here's the argument Trump offered in his tweet for making a massive investment in infrastructure now:

"With interest rates for the United States being at ZERO, this is the time to do our decades long awaited Infrastructure Bill. It should be VERY BIG & BOLD, Two Trillion Dollars, and be focused solely on jobs and rebuilding the once great infrastructure of our Country! Phase 4"

The "ZERO" Trump is referring to is the target the Federal Reserve has set for short-term interest rates. But the Treasury doesn't finance the federal government's $18-trillion public debt by borrowing the money 30 days at a time. Instead, it issues a mix of short- and long-term securities, and it expects to pay $482 billion in interest on the public debt this fiscal year. That works out, on average, to an annual interest rate of 2.6%.

With the global economy tanking and investors snapping up Treasury notes, the interest rates Washington has to pay on the money it borrows have dropped. But they're not going to be zero. Meanwhile, the total cost of Washington's borrowing is almost certain to rise, given that the recently enacted $2-trillion economic rescue bill, like the much smaller coronavirus emergency measures passed in previous weeks, is financed entirely with deficit spending. The federal government was already running about $1 trillion in the red annually, so its public debt is easily going to surpass $20 trillion as a consequence of the actions already taken.

(Don't forget that as the economy slides toward recession, the federal tax receipts will drop, further expanding the deficit.)

Before the COVID-19 pandemic, the federal government was projected to spend more than 10% of its budget on debt service, with that share rising almost to 13% by fiscal 2026. Those are dollars that provide no services, employ no people and deliver no benefits to the taxpaying public. That percentage is going to jump now, thanks to the pandemic and the money Congress is appropriating to get us through it.

Which brings us to the merits of a massive infrastructure package at this moment. Conventional wisdom holds that funding a lot more road, bridge and water projects is a good way to stimulate the economy, in part because it boosts productivity more than many other types of federal spending do. But a recent review of the research on this point found no clear proof that infrastructure spending lived up to its billing.

According to the authors, the effectiveness of the approach "likely depends on the nature of the spending, whether it can be implemented quickly, the condition of the existing transportation infrastructure, and the nature of the recession."

In other words, the devil's in the details. Today, the best-case scenario is that the downturn will be sharp but brief, with the economy rebounding swiftly after the outbreak is fully contained and the social distancing controls are removed. If that's the case, pouring a couple trillion dollars into projects that won't get started for a year or more seems like it would be too much help arriving far too late.

A more likely outcome is that the restrictions that are dragging down the economy will remain in place for months, until testing has scaled up dramatically and at least one effective treatment for COVID-19 is approved. The longer the downturn endures, the more protracted the recovery will probably be. In that case, spending heavily on infrastructure could make more sense, assuming the projects are truly "shovel ready" - a label often used to describe the transportation projects in the 2009 stimulus package, but not always deserved.

One other thing to consider is that, recession or no recession, this country's infrastructure needs a lot more work than we've been giving it. Still, it's not helpful to pretend that there's no cost to borrowing the money needed to finance these projects. Given the deep, deep hole Washington is already digging, lawmakers need to tailor their infrastructure ambitions to the unique situation we're in.



Jon Healey is the Los Angeles Times' deputy editorial page editor.

Visit the Los Angeles Times at


Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

It has often occurred to me that the appropriate response to some of the ridiculous things President Donald Trump utters is: "He's an idiot." Don't get me wrong (as op-ed writers like to say). I'm not impugning Trump's IQ. By "idiot" I mean something a bit different: that Trump often doesn't know what he's talking about. (That doesn't exclude the possibility that some of his misrepresentations ...

In mid-April, I received a message from the nursing home in Connecticut where my mother lives. When I called back, a doctor told me, "your mother has a fever." Those were words I'd been dreading and expecting. "We assume it's COVID," the doctor said. My 80-year-old mother was comfortable for the time being. Her fever wasn't very high and she was breathing okay. But the doctor said not to take ...

My junior and senior years in high school were 1968 and 1969; five decades later, I can still remember some of the main events of that era: the assassinations of Martin Luther King and Robert F. Kennedy, the bombing of Cambodia, the Apollo 8 spaceflight that orbited the moon, and Woodstock, which I pleaded with my parents to let me attend. (They said no.) In my personal life, I remember ...

If Joe Biden is counting on African American votes to win the White House in November, he may want to reboot his outreach strategy. During a radio interview Friday morning with Charlamagne tha God on the nationally syndicated, "The Breakfast Club," Biden said that "if you have a problem figuring out whether you're for me or Trump, then you ain't black." It took a handful of nanoseconds for the ...

If there is a silver lining to the flawed U.S. response to the coronavirus pandemic, it is this: The relatively high number of new cases being diagnosed daily - upward of 20,000 - will make it easier to test new vaccines. To determine whether a vaccine prevents disease, the study's subjects need to be exposed to the pathogen as it circulates in the population. Reopening the economy will likely ...

This is how a thug acts. Twitter at long last has affixed fact-check links to a couple of tweets by President Donald Trump that include verifiably false details, in this case claims by the president that mail-in balloting leads to election fraud. Note that Twitter didn't remove the tweets, and hasn't gone so far as to add fact-check links to the president's baseless insinuations that MSNBC ...

California and 22 other states are taking the Trump administration to court - again - in an attempt to block President Donald Trump's foolishly destructive effort to weaken fuel economy standards. Since he took office, Trump has been on a mission to roll back the Obama-era fuel efficiency regulation that was the nation's most important effort to cut automobile pollution, reduce oil consumption ...

This is a solemn and challenging time in the life of our nation and world. A remorseless, invisible enemy threatens the elderly and vulnerable among us - and some of the healthiest, too. It challenges our sense of safety, security and community. Our children are separated from their teachers and their friends in a way that is hard for them to understand. Many have lost loved ones, jobs and ...

Sadly but predictably, the snake oil cures and scams meant to exploit the coronavirus crisis for personal gain seem endless. But perhaps the greatest scam was the one approved by Congress with overwhelming bipartisan support and signed into law by President Donald Trump on March 27. The $2 trillion rescue measure known as the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act delivered a $135 ...

Will your neighborhood school open on schedule in the fall? The answer should vary by location, but some headline-grabbing declarations are prolonging the uncertainty for families and students. And uncertainty leads to fear - an infectious state of mind best treated with a dose of common sense. Special-interest groups encouraged educators to "scream bloody murder" if collective bargaining and ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News