Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

Diverse ways of identifying gifted students

  • 0

In her story, “Struggling to define excellent” (Casper Star-Tribune, Oct. 7), Leah Todd notes that some school districts in Wyoming rely on standardized tests to identify gifted children. I agree that standardized tests can be one useful basis for identifying gifted children, but it is not optimal to rely exclusively on standardized tests for such identification. There are three reasons why.

First, standardized tests are fairly narrow in the range of skills they assess (usually, knowledge and analytical reasoning with that knowledge), whereas giftedness comes in many and diverse forms. Students can be gifted scientists, mathematicians, writers, artists, or musicians, among other things. They can be analytically gifted, or creatively or practically gifted. They can be gifted in schoolwork or gifted in their pursuits outside the classroom. No one standardized test adequately will capture the range of gifts children display.

Second, all tests involve error of measurement. The younger the children are who are tested, the higher the level of error and thus the less reliable the judgments that can be made from test scores. Not all people are good standardized test-takers, and young children are notoriously variable in their test-taking skills. The risk of relying too heavily on a standardized test is that one will identify children who are gifted, but especially at taking standardized tests.

Third, children develop at remarkably different rates. Some excel early and then flame out quickly. Others excel later and then keep going. Some stand out at all points in their careers. Whatever measurements we use, we need to remember that children are dynamic, not static in their development, so we will want to reassess them often. We do not want to risk giving a standardized test to young students and then assuming that whatever they score then, that’s where they will end up.

There are broad models for identifying the gifted that go beyond standardized tests. I hope that districts will look into some of these options. For example, Joseph Renzulli has suggested identifying children on the basis of above-average ability, creativity, and task commitment (motivation). Howard Gardner has recommended looking at what he calls “multiple intelligences”: linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily-kinesthetic, naturalist, interpersonal, and intrapersonal. I have suggested identifying gifted children on the basis of analytical, creative, practical, and wisdom-based/ethical skills. All of these models also offer assessments techniques for measuring these varied skills. The models have in common that they recognize that there is more to a child, and to giftedness in a child, than a score on a standardized test.

I would hope that school districts in Wyoming would consider using standardized tests for identification of the gifted only in conjunction with other measures and broader models. They will be doing a service not only to the children, but also to the development of the very best talent pool for our state.

Robert J. Sternberg is president of the University of Wyoming and a former president of the American Psychological Association as well as treasurer of the Association of American Colleges and Universities. The views in this letter, however, are only his own.


Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Stubson writes: This past weekend the Wyoming GOP held its quarterly State Central Committee meeting, the outcome of which was a flurry of asinine resolutions best characterized as clubby playground tattling. The Central Committee’s actions also thrust my party into the national dialogue as the latest example of political party dysfunction.

Hunkins writes: It wasn’t far into my routine before I forgot breakfast and sat down to listen and watch Lamb’s fascinating interview with a newly elected representative to the Virginia House of Delegates, a young, articulate and conservative Black woman from Norfolk, Virginia.

Adler writes: The Court cut the ground from beneath its landmark ruling with a wounding declaration that the president enjoys a “limited” executive privilege: “The privilege is fundamental to the operation of Government and inextricably rooted in the separation of powers under the Constitution.”

Barron writes: 

The ballot item failed by only 116 votes in an election where voters passed every thing else including $10 million for a new senior center. The total approved menu called for spending $128 million for 13 propositions and more than 60 projects.

Rudkin writes: 

I can’t help but make the connection between this place and what God does in the hearts and minds of those who choose to trust him. God has always been in the business of restoring, taking hearts that are bone tired, skeptical, broken down by the cares of this life and breathing beauty into them again.

The Washington, D.C.-based Federal Bureau of Investigation has lost all credibility as a disinterested investigatory agency. Now we learn from…

Rancher Shelagh Wulff Wisdom writes: Something transpires that changes everything when you become a devotee of horses. Priorities change their focus. You want to provide everything to that animal that he needs. You start to become a part of that horse at the very same time he starts becoming a part of you.

I love Thanksgiving. I love preparing the food all day and enjoying it while sitting around a table with some of the people I love most. And t…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News